Tuesday 31 March 2009

Comparative Analysis - Fight Club & American Beauty Characters

Characters in Fight Club

Jack

Tyler Durden (Jack's alter ego)

Marla
Bob

Characters in American Beauty

Lester Burnham

Carolyn Burnham


Jane Burnham

Angela


Frank Fitz

Ricky Fitts

Jack and Lester - both struggling with masclinity whilst trying to re-define themselves. They both live joyless lives, they are consumers seeking happiness.

Jack and Carolyn - both pro-consumerist ideology to fulfil mental happiness, but deep down they are very unhappy.

Tyler and Lester - both quest for physical embodiment/ power, strength, endurance.

Tyler and Ricky - both observers/voyerisitc.

Tyler and Frank - both believe in traditional fighting values. (Frank forever wanting his son to fight back).

Frank and Bob - the most feminim characters in the films. Bob = no balls, 'bitch tits' Frank = he break downs, he cries, qualities of a woman.

Marla and Angela - both searching for gradification and fulfillment. They both have a constructed identity and deep insecurities, creating a false persona. They both crave male attention and in a sense are lost, they don't know what to do with themselves.

Marla and Jane - both disfuntional characters that don't fit in and the two of them are different representations of beauty. They challenge the ideologies of feminity and beauty, but are beautiful in their own right.

Marla, Angela and Jane - the three crave male attention. for Jane it's about male human contact, not sexually driven. She craves a father figure and some sort of relationship with her father. Whereas for Angela and Jane, they crave sexual attention from men in order to feel better about themselves.

Comparative Analysis - Fight Club & American Beauty Opening Sequences

Both films conform to the expectations of a title sequence by:
- Introducing a protagonist
- Establishing a narrative
- Drawing the audience in

How are they similar?
- Both openings immediately challenge the American Dream through narrative
- Both openings feature a voice-over
- Both openings start at the end
- Both openings work hard to establish character, mood, tone, pace and thematics (The thematics being: dysfunctional families, destruction, anarchy, consumerism, power, control and most importantly subverting the Dream).

Both protagonists (Jack, Fight Club and Lester, American Beauty) are disfuntional, imprisoned, dissatisfied. On the face of it the two opening sequences look completely different, the cinematography in Fight Club is nothing like the cinematography in American Beauty. The score/soundtrack is different also, but these openings both take the audience on a journey through the characters and their mindsets.